I had forgotten about Saul's: I had forgotten about Saul's stature, and I thank you for reminding me of that. And yes, he sent a militarily inexperienced adolescent to fight the battle, and I think Goliath and Saul were sharply surprised by the day's events. And you are right about the many Goliaths that surround us.
There's so much depth in this: There's so much depth in this delicate, pocket-sized parable. It speaks of unshakable dignity, tenacity and the ability to see our worth even after being broken. In fact, you powerfully imply that the devastation created even more value. A highly evolved and inspiring analogy.
This is amazing. And: This is amazing. And disconcerting. First, AI perfects art and now poetry? Actually, the small flaws, the quirks and surprises in human writing make it more enjoyable, so Tap has nothing on humans.
It's impressive that you were able to pick up on clues that Tap wasn't all that he appeared to be. You outsmarted the smart poet. Fascinating post.
There's an awe-inspiring: There's an awe-inspiring sense of triumph and ascension in this highly symbolic and intriguing work of art. I read it three times because I loved the poetic gymnastics and the surreal brilliance of it. Amazing!
Short concise lines, and a: Short concise lines, and a compact length: and yet, you have summarized as profoundly as, say, Plato, the philosophy of resilience---of which many of us (and some of us who have been bullied for embracing our natures) have, or will acquire, a deep knowledge. This is a brave poem to post, and it will encourage others most certainly!
An interesting mediational: An interesting mediational note! In the panic and desperation Saul puts all upon the the little shepherd boy, Saul being a head taller than the Israelites.
And David was more defender than offensive warrior. An apt image in the situation. And of Goliath's thoughts. Well, we live in a world of Goliaths, demi-Goliaths and wannabe Goliaths.
The reflection of others on: The reflection of others on the waters of our existence is quite a journal of depth and interest.
This is quite an entrancing concept more so when these others fill in their presence with intentionality or relational consummation rather than toxic consumption.
Your having highlighted those: Your having highlighted those lines demonstrates the core fear being expressed- that inextricable feeling of helplessness in the path of a fast forming snowballing avalanche that swallows everything in its trajectory. Thank you for your kindness on this poem, its communication is returning full circle.
That was quite a challenge,: That was quite a challenge, the fifth couplet, as to structural dynamic and effecting organic unity rather than just tossing up a salad of thought and image. It is also an exploration on how to bring about the poetry of of historical personages and events that have more than one point of view or interpretation, i.e., in the case of Jack the Ripper to mention a quite obvious case. Most of our information comes from time honoured acceptance even if there are other versions of the truth available as in the historical accuracy of Shakespearean literature, et al. How we are remembered and 'peddled' isn't hardly ever within our power to manage or control. The world will choose to remember they way it suits. Thanks kindly.
That's quite envigorating: That's quite envigorating Starward! Thanks for sharing your thoughts. It definitely isn't a misreading as the dynamics of your take are quite in keeping with the inspiration of this poem. 'The hand that is no longer' is a strange and alluring idea that begs to be articulated. It also allows for the idea that we are although connected throughout our waking days are for periods of time (shorter or longer) separate from each other. And that opens up other avenues in the meditations on relationships and human bonds and beyond. How exciting for you to have began that exploration through this 'portal' poem. Again, my gratitude, Rik.
To me, the poem mingles the: To me, the poem mingles the romantic with the eerie---and I hope I am not misreading (please tell me, though, if I am missing something). Even the spring morning is melting away, and that, too, is a little eerie. But the eeriest detail is the shadow of the hand (the hand implied to be missing, or withdrawn), but held tight in the night hours. I think of a scene of handholding in Shirley Jackson's novel, The Haunting, which some have declared to be the greatest ghost story ever written (and, most of the time, I agree): and that hand that was being held, in her novel, is spectral, long dead, and motivated to horrify and drive the main character into madness and death. I love poems that resonate so well that they lead me to think of other things I have read (like the The Waste Land does), and this poem, in its very compact and succinct way, does exactly that!
That fifth couplet is very: That fifth couplet is very wise, very astute, and very shrewd. The whole poem implies quite a backstory about that tragedy your note mentions.
The third line gives a cold: The third line gives a cold chill, then the sixth line sounds almost playful with its alliteration, and then the huge impact of that last line with the cattlecars ready to roll behind a locomotive belching coalsmoke, and into the camps where the crematories belch human fleshsmoke.
The phrase that occupies the: The phrase that occupies the last four lines of this poem is really, really powerful. The textures of my todays, when I was young, were certainly instruments of torture more often than not, and I shudder to think of them.