Would A Comma Hurt?: Okay, 6th read and ?'s but that worked cause I sailed on "...gift wrapped promises..." the dash and space helped to finish the one line poem. Wow! Can she write! ~S~
Beautiful use of imagery, and: Beautiful use of imagery, and the several repetitions of the title as lines in the poem is a very subtle strategy, and gives the poem a structure and a haunting sound. This is a very good poem, and I am glad I read it tonight.
Your consistent cosmic vision: Your consistent cosmic vision can even transform a graduation ceremony: wow! Only a poet of your stature would be able to place this kind of event within a more cosmological framework, bringing the very stars into participation, marshalliing both the past and the future together as one process (which they really are). I have remarked, on other poems, about the comforting consistency of your cosmic vision. To see it deployed in this context is to see a skilled artist who can make any event, any incident, any emotion a part of that consistency.
In some ways, this poem: In some ways, this poem reminds me (in general, but not in specific details) of the Russian aristocracy's---and imperial bureaucracy's---response to the Revolution of 1905, which was peaceful, Christian, and understated until met with intolerance, inclement hostility, and physical violence. The Russian workers and peasants wanted to share in the wealth---not to strut up and down the streets of Moscow and Saint Petersburg, but to find an additional means to survive the horrid conditions in which they lived and labored. Rejected by the unreasonable and selfish bureaucracy, they turned, instead, to the Bolshevik party which brought that failed and vengeful lawyer, Lenin, to the pinnacle of murderous power, and, later, allowed his even more murderous henchman Stalin to plunge the Soviet Union into a bloodbath that lasted well into the thirties and early forties. When society, overall, meets its neediest members with a cavalier lack of sympathy, accusing them of being Takers with nothing to give back, they will choose a vanguard leadership that prefers bloodshed to negotiation. You might consult Herman Meville's poem, "The Martyr" on the assassination of Abraham Lincoln: "Beware the People weeping / when they bare the iron hand."
Thank you for that mention,: Thank you for that mention, and yes, she is very good, isn't she? I think we will be seeing her continuing excellence as she posts some more in what I hope is the very near future.
I have not read any of them,: I have not read any of them, but I would like to point out something about them. Those of your poems that I have read are very good. That has to come from somewhere and, as is the case with most poets, its nascent presence can be seen in their early poems---and that is very interesting. I will cite just two cases in support of this. There are a couple of poems supposedly written by the ancient Roman poet, Vergil, which, according to the legend, he himself suppressed. Yet they were good enough to have been preserbed, and ascribed to him, in a time from which we have relatively little. And when one reads them, one can see the first stirrings of the greatness he brought to his first two collections and the great epic he wrote. And, a more contemporary example from the twentieth century: when I was a teenager, the great poem of the twentieth century was considered to be T S Eliot's poem, Ths Waste Land. (I studied it incessantly at college, and I still love it.) The poem was published in 1922, in the form we now have. But in the mid-seventies, the poet's widow published the recently discovered original manuscripts, and readers and scholars learned that the original draft included some poems that Eliot had written in his college years, and he had worked them into the massive structure of the original. (This manuscript was then submitted to a fellow poet, Ezra Pound, who ruthlessly slashed it down from 2000 or so lines to 434, to give us the form that was published in 1922. During that editing process, Eliot was not even present, as he was having a nervous breakdown in Switzerland.) These early poems, while not as great as the "retained" parts of The Waste Land, are still very, very interesting, and some of them are extremely moving. One line from one of them, which I used to recite to myself during my freshman year, was "And in the evening, through lace curtains, the aspidestra grieves." I thought a grieving houseplant was a wonderful metaphor, and Eliot was the same age when he wrote it that I was when I read it. Pound, who was still alive at the time the manuscript was published, was shown the actual original drafts with his slash-marks and snide comments written upon them. Mrs. Eliot said that, upon lookinjg at these originals after fifty years, Pound began weeping and said, "Why, oh why, did he not restore the cancelled passages? Why did he listen to me?" And some of the poems, over which Pound wept, were from Eliot's earliest writing period. And in some of them were flashes and glimpses of the greatness for which he would be considered, until Wallace Stevens' star began to ascend in the early seventies, to be the greatest poet of the entire twentieth century. (At college, I actually met a person who had known Eliot; and a very sophomoric letter sent to his widow, Valerie, was honored with a very encouraging letter from her, typed by her personally and scented with lilac perfume.) I have said all that to say this: do not discount your early work because you, yourself, might dislike it---as did Vergil and Eliot. I will cite one more example, and if I have been too verbose, you can easily delete the comment. I am a devout, but very flawed, Christian. But I would never, ever, dare disparage or discount of the Gospel of Saint Mark because it is not as theologically profound as, say, the Gospel of Saint John. Mark's Gospel is our first, our very first, written glimpse of Jesus---and that is as valuable, in that aspect, as the other accounts that followed and were more elaborate and more literate (they tell me that Mark's Greek grammar is the worst in the New Testament). Early work---whether among the Gospels, or in literary history, or in your own personal writing curve---is valuable for its own sake. And besides, one of the traditions of Western literature is that the poet is not as competent as the reader in determining what is good, bad, valuable, or valueless, in the work as a whole. Neither you nor I are better judges of our early work than Saint Mark was of his, or Eliot and Pound was of theirs. That is for our readers, or literary scholars, to determine after our work, our personal canon, has been completed and closed. If I have been verbose here, it is only because my response to those poems of yours that I have read had emboldened me to share this with you. I think your poetry is very talented, and, of course, a towering skyscraper does have to stand on some kind of foundation.