Wow! Only a Poet of: Wow! Only a Poet of Patricia's stature could make a cicada poem this successful. I will bring to this comment a term which, I believe, has not been used by any other commentor: this is what I would call a legacy poem. I derive this term from certain, mostly science fiction, tales or poems that speak in terms comparing what had been to what is left, with the former usually a pleasantly bucolic environment, and the remaining situation a wreckage of that. It is, basically, a variation on the theme of humanity's expulsion from Eden due to bad choices. Back in the dinosaur days of the early seventies, I read a short story where an audio time capsule is uncovered, and the speaker apologizes to the listeners about the state of the world that the listeners have inherited, as compared to the beauty of it that the speaker once knew, and then saw being destroyed. The last line reveals that the time capsule's speach was never understood, because it was discovered by ants, and ants have no hearing apparatus. I have never forgotten either the horror of that story, or the poignancy of the speaker's great regret. My very first foray into writing science fiction (to which I aspired before I considered poetry) was a legacy tale. It ultimaely failed, but it was fun to write during my sophomore year. This poem is not science fiction, of course, and at its end one does not hear the voice of Charlton Heston screaming, "Soylent green is people!" But the poem's center of gravity is given to us in the first five lines---which is unusual for this Poet who, customarily (and like Pop Stevens) encloses the centers of gravity toward the middle of the poem, generally. But by leading with this, she establishes the point of the poem immediately and starts the process with or without our assistance---like the voice in that time capsule discovered by the ants. (BTW, I was did not have sufficient foresight, in seventh grade, to write down the title of that tale, or the author, so I cannot cite it here. I have never seen it since.) The imagery presented by the poem is described with her customary succintness---she has the ability to state an image in a few words, but with no doubt as to what she is stating, or why, or how it fits into the poem. William Golding wrote a novel called The Inheritors, in which the last Neanderthal human beings see their world inherited by the Cro Magnons, and the innocent and bucolic world of the Neanderthal people will become, at the hands of Cro Magnons, corrupted in preparation for the world our form of the species will create. (And yes, I must use other literary comparisons because this poem is too profound for me just to say, Gosh, I like this, and the imagery is pretty.) And, lastly, I will compare this poem to one of my most favorite authors, the great and mononymic writer, Trevanian, and the novel I consider his greatest triumph, The Summer Of Katya (which I highly recommend to any readers of this comment). In the Katya novel, the speaker is narrating a love story from the summer that immediately preceded the commencement of WWI: what he called the Age of Grace giving way to the Age of Efficiency---that is, the efficiency of death, as, in that war, the discoveries of science were turned to beligerent purposes, for the first time in human history. This created a gap between two worlds, and a gap so vast that there was no going back, for the speaker, for Katya, and for us. This is what Patricia's poem essentially tells us. She says, "We loved our manufactured joy more than / what was free." This is an answer in assent to the Katya novel---to the love of manufactured processes that led to the murderous efficiency of places like Auschwitz and Belsen; and to the dropping of a metallic cannister over Aoi Bridge in Hiroshima, Japan, in August, 1945. There was no going back to the world that those devices closed to us. This is what Patricia is teling us, adding her very original voice and perceptions to those of one of her greatest peers, Trevanian. And I applaud this until the palms of my hands sting from clapping. I have compared her poetry, her insights, and her verbal skill to that of Wallace Stevens; now I compare her, with the utmost admiration, to the greatness of Trevanian. Although he has left our world, I am sure he would have acknowledged her greatness as well; and that is what I have tried to do here, with regard to this magnificent, triumphant, but ultimarely gut-wrenching poem.
Just looking through your: Just looking through your work. I appreciate you taking a look at one of my pieces of vomit. Very cool poem. Well written images.
Something about this has me: Something about this has me feeling as if Bob Dylan, Don McLain, and Bruce Springstein circa Blinded By The Light all had a love child together on your piece of paper. I say that not to short change you at all. Whose ever love child this poem may be, you lit the candles, you set the mood, and you were the matchmaker.
My favorite line: "the sand is deafening". I could hear it the moment I read it.
My dad grew a lemon tree from: You have inspired a story I wish to share. My dad grew a lemon tree from the seeds of one when I was young. We had it for many years, potted so it could go inside during the winter, until a drug addict stole it consecutive weeks. The first time, we happened to be coming back from church and saw an incredibly high individual walking off with it. When my dad confronted him, the addict insisted it was his lemon tree. I guess he was taking it out for a walk ; ) Unfortunately, the next week, presumably the same guy had better timing in grabbing the tree to sell for his next fix. Lemon hiding is an artform, indeed, in more ways than just that you speak of. Like the addict in my childhood, the corporatist will stop at nothing to take our lemons.
Forgive me chiming in, but I: Forgive me chiming in, but I feel the greatest offense may have been for your daughter to remove you from the life of your grandchildren for a whole year over a single phrase on facebook. That seems cruel to them, in addition to you. Your body of work towards your children's lives (and grandchildren) should outway two words on an electronic page, and I have a faith from your words that you have given a life to love and care, even if (like all of us) imperfect.
I don't quite know how to diagnose the way people have allowed things such as facebook to turn relatively resolvable issues into relationship crippling wars, but they only reason I'm going to withhold words such as "insanity" is because your loved ones are involved and I wish no disrespect, rather only to say that your mistake is not one to be crucified over, so please don't crucify yourself. I pray that your children can now quickly come to look at your longer body of work and give you due benefit of the doubt you sure seem to deserve.